Yes, the scale will cache the value and upload when Wi-Fi reconnects. No login required. Even on an uneven HARD floor, you WILL get poor readings (I did! If you donât have Garmin devices, then frankly the appeal evaporates pretty quickly, and there are other scales that cost just half of the Garmin scale with basically the same features. Best Overall. Do you stick to imperial metrics because of your audience or is a sentimental thing? Thank you for the review â I do have a question: âHow would this type of scale help me lose weight vs a $30 digital scale?â Let start by saying that I am 51 â 5â 8â and 220 pounds and have been cycling since the 80s. Here I am thinking I need to lose some weight and I find out I am the same height and weight as the great Ray Maker!!! If you burn fat and your weight goes down while keeping the amount of water constant, your water percentage will go up. I had this issue with my scale as well. Fossil Gen 5 Review | Top 10 Best Wear OS smartwatch, NRC P-Ride Review | HOCO | cycling eyewear sunglasses glasses review, Review of SmrT Cargo Water Bottle | Mini Review, Garmin HRM-PRO Review | The greatest ever could still be better, Polar Vantage V2 Review ð¥ Pro Triathlon Watch – one of the best, Garmin 745 Review | Small Format, High-End Forerunner For Triathlon, Garmin Venu SQ Review & Verdict | Comparison Apple Watch, Fitbit Sense. – Bone Mass Maybe if Garmin didnt charge a fortune for their dev tools – there would be more dev’s working on their platform. Fat percentage can never be measured accurately, but when the number coming out of the instrument is based more on some known averages (not constants!) Or are there problems to be expected because of the lower voltage? There hasn’t been a fee for the dev/API access for a few years. I have the original Index and see my weight data in health. No, athlete mode is disabled on my Nokia/Withings Body+. Also, while on the back of the scale youâll notice two things you can poke at (besides the springs on the battery compartment). Generally, I think I did that each day all the Garmin results seemed plausible when compared to previous results. Or these years. Press and hold the button on the back. you could use an ant+ dongle on a Pc Does the scale acknowledged that the weight was before or after a workout which may cause weight loss? #Annoying, some people would rather not be reminded of that. But unlike Withings or Fitbit, thereâs no clear landing page on all the services/partners Garmin supports here. On your app screenshot, it looks like it is based on the last weight-in (blue dot) recorded per day. Is Garmin fixed this somehow with integration with this scale? Monitoring any muscle wastage/atrophy could have been of some use but it’s sometimes equally as easy to use your eyes to see that someone is struggling to stand rather than needing technology to re-affirm the visually obvious. Have you done any comparisons with weight with other scales? The original Garmin Index Scale not only measures body mass but also Body Mass Index, Bone Mass, Muscle Mass, Water Percentage and Body Fat Percentage. Its entire point in life is to be a CONNECTED scale. Why haven’t you yet released a review for XYZ product you mentioned months ago? Let’s deal with the easy case, your live-in partner wants to get access to your shiny new scales. 1. Isn’t that logical? But I do agree, it seems like a great example of a no-brainer type widget Garmin could add to their own watches relatively easily. Conclusion is than that S2 is somehow trying to measure body fat in contrast to S1 which is just pretending to do so. It compartmentalizes them into individual time stamped entries per weigh in, so no funny business with only taking the last weigh-in of the day or syncing at a certain time or anything like that. This content is not sponsored. The older scale I currently use has never provided a higher weight reading seven days in a row without my clothing fitting a little bit tighter. BC1000 was 190EUR in 2011 and the BC1500 is holding the price level of 400EUR since 2009…. Now, how do I get YouTube running on that display? In Ray’s image elsewhere in the comments, it has him at 12.4 lbs of bone mass as well. This is a slight change from the Index 1 scale, where I can simply step on. . Yes, the Garmin Index Scale is designed to work in the Garmin Connect environment as well as to optionally send measurements to other apps such as Apple Health. This is with an old Tanita, and another brand I picked up at Meijer while we were at my family’s cabin. Usually quite a bit off. Hereâs a closer look at the feet and batteries. From this moment forward itâll look worse, even if you never touch it. I’m planning a post out on that today. Taking this a step further, after a workout, Garmin estimates your water loss, I wonder if they could actually track my water loss through my weight change if done immediately before and after. I know it’s probably not a big money spinner but realistically the things that were wrong with wifi scales 5 years ago are still wrong and yet they’re all easy to fix, with the major one being a simple open API in both directions. It this “normal” or should I return it? Or accurate ? Inbound is basically impossible. Thatâs in addition to all the baseline bits it previously did: – Measures weight (lbs/stones/kg) Glossary. I donât care if my weight increases if my BF% is falling. . Have you observed this or heard anything from Garmin on this phenomenon? Each seemed confident they were correct. Then, I come here and write about my adventures. This is where youâll grab your smartphone to set it up, using the Garmin Connect app. 10% discount (the5krunner10) at Power Meter City (USA). Â Some reviews are over 60 pages long when printed out, with hundreds of photos! So, Wyze scale? I really with more companies would take the route of Withings (e.g. B) Write access (such as how Zwift or TrainreRoad pushes workout files to Garmin Connect isn’t included here, that’s still behind double-secret backdoor (basically, you have to be a household name in the sports world and not massively compete with Garmin). As you probably noticed by looking below, I also take time to answer all the questions posted in the comments â and thereâs quite a bit of detail in there as well. How multiple weight-ins per day are calculated? Some of their newer devices are getting mixed reviews, maybe as they move away from their basic cam expertise. Unless by some strange miracle I have been able to hold 7% body fat for 19 straight months. No problem, the product comparison data is constantly updated with new products and new features added to old products! Thereâs no technical differences between those two to my knowledge, and Garmin isnât clear either if perhaps it was resolved by a software update that occurred moments later on the scale. Let's be honest, tracking all those steps with a fitness wearable is nice. Is it 2020 or am I still living in the 1990s? A short press allows you to connect an additional WiFi network, a long press resets the scales. Believe me Ray, in the future there will come a day when your mile times become your Kilometre times. Looks like another scale that won’t really work well on carpet, even with those feet. I would have thought I was a bit lower than 16% as I’m pretty skinny, thus the Garmin gave readings that seemed to me to be more likely to be correct. No, that’s not the reason. I got a difference of 0.7kg this morning, 83.0kg with the Fenix 5+ on and 83.7kg without it. ), so make sure all 4 legs are properly in contact with a hard surface. Although when comparing it to the Tanita-random-number-generator it’s great value-for-money. Here are some options which are cheaper but mostly not as good as the Garmin Scale. Having a physical switch that would fix it on one unit would be an advantage. In Healthy Edge software (desktop) – Tweaked some algorithms related to body fat & other impedance-based measurements (based on increased sensitivity of sensors) And of course â you can always sign-up to be a DCR Supporter! The water loss estimation is done in-device on the newer devices. Or, you can just delete the data point afterwards on Garmin Connect (smartphone or web). You'll support the site, and get ad-free DCR! Even Changing activity class can change readings as DesFit shows in his video: link to youtu.be so I would assume that changing age will have a huge impact. As long as the Tanita keep on going, and the app works, I stick with my current set up. Thanks in advance. For sure. and is that reliable. Click this link to enter your question. Weight itself is repeatable and lines up with 2 other scales I have (an old Withings and some generic bathroom scale). Click this link to enter your question. Do you know if this has been rectified, at least to give a more gradual phasing of algorithms between different Activity Levels? ð *NOT* the top-end CARDIO model, that’s twice the price for little benefit. Weight, Water %, % Fat, BMI, and Muscle Mass are what get pushed over from Garmin Connect to Training Peaks instantaneously via the Garmin Health Sync thing that’s referenced in Ray’s article. Yes, the equipment is quite expensive. And the price is 1/3. Obviously, it’s not recommended to wear socks since that’ll impact things. What also frustrates me is that there should be some way to say ‘Hey scale I just had a DXA scan done and these are my REAL results’ – can you calibrate yourself based on that – I can’t believe that is a hard thing to do, but none of the scales offers it… Feedback to Garmin, With the old Tanita, the measurement is being stored: A) This is for read-only access to GC data (or, utilization of the transfer API’s like workout/courses) What are you using to sync the data? There is not body fat settings in GC so this was the only solution for proper calories calculations.